17 January 2019

The City in Ruins: An Ecumenical Vision Betrayed




Rev. Thomas John



(As the Church of South India goes through an extremely difficult phase in its life and history, www.savecsi.net would like to republish, albeit with minor revisions, an article written by Rev. Thomas John, titled The City in Ruins: The Story of an Ecumenical Vision Betrayed. This article, originally published in October 2011, is quite prophetic, and urges the laity to assume their central role in the church and assert their power to change things around. It argues that the congregation should be the centre and focus of being a church in the world. The one, holy, catholic, apostolic church is found in all its fullness in the life of the local worshipping community. Hence, it is only the right ecclesiology and the right missiology that can save CSI from its present predicament.)





It has come to be recognized across the board by the Indian nation, or for that matter by the world over, that true democracy can be realized only through devolution of power to the people through self-governing institutions at a very local level of community organization. The 73rd amendment Act of 1992 requires Panchayati Raj institutions to be endowed with adequate responsibilities and powers so that they may be enabled to function as “institutions of self-government”. Sweeping legislations are being made across the various states in India to follow up on this amendment. But, this change in perspective and understanding has not yet influenced the thinking of church leadership in India, especially in regard to the nature of church polity and administration. Although, some of the recent judgments of the Supreme Court of India have forced the Syrian Churches in India to decide their disputes taking the majority view of the congregations, thus acknowledging the supremacy of congregations over the prescriptions of Patriarchates and Catholicates.





In this backdrop, it is important to look at the turn of events in the Church of South India (CSI) which have somehow made the episcopacy and the diocesan polity into instruments for arbitrary and ruthless exercise of power over the congregations. The congregations no longer have any say in matters regarding the appointment of their pastors and the alienation of their valuable properties, often bequeathed to them by the missionaries or their ancestors. The episcopate, abetted by an authoritarian, caste-ridden and patriarchal cultural ethos, has become dictatorial. Bishops consider dioceses as their fiefdom; constitution is given a go by and constitutional bodies have been made to subserve the interests of the bishops through a mystique of divine power, arbitrary exercise of “ecclesiastical authority” and threats of punishments, and dolling out of largesse. Power has become concentrated in the hands of a coterie, undermining democratic functioning of elected bodies. Thus, corruption and mismanagement of church properties has become institutionalised.





The CSI has a church polity in which pastorate committees, except for the chairperson, have very limited autonomy or administrative powers. The chairperson of the pastorate committee can only be a member of the ordained clergy (the presbyter in charge) and whose primary loyalty is to the bishop, from whom he derives his power. The Governing Principles of the CSI Constitution, while acknowledging the role of the pastorate committees as having general oversight of the pastorates, gives the dioceses the right to lay down “the manner and limitations of their oversight”. While all the administrative functions of the pastorate committee are delegated to the chairperson, all the spiritual duties are listed under the tasks of elders such as “helping” the presbyter, “visiting” the sick, settling disputes, “read lessons”, “help the pastor in conducting of Divine service”, "collection of subscriptions and contributions”, “zealous in spreading the Kingdom of God” and so on (Constitution of the CSI North Kerala Diocese). The constitution has effectively turned the people in the pew and the pastorate committees into ciphers. The latter have no say even in the “arrangement and introduction or removal of furniture inside the church”. The clergy change every three to four years and yet, those permanent members of the congregation who have laboured for the construction of the church, and contributed to its growth immensely for many years must silently suffer the hubris of a new pastor who, with the blessings of yet another new bishop, push “furniture”, people and tradition around according to their whims and fancies with callous disregard for the members in the pew and the pastorate committee.





While the Governing Principles of the CSI Constitution very feebly affirm, “every pastorate shall have certain authority within its area, shall have certain responsibilities in Church Discipline, and shall have an opportunity of expressing its judgment both as to the appointment of its pastor and the selection of candidates for ordination from that pastorate”, in reality, the constitutions of the dioceses do not treat them with any sense of rights and dignity nearing what is described therein. The next layer higher up in the hierarchy is that of the bishops and the dioceses. In the diocesan structure the bishops are given extraordinary powers. They, in turn, transfer this to the clergy ensuring that they remain loyal to the bishops rather than to the pastorates and the people who support them financially by their subscriptions and tithes. However, there is no clearly laid out procedures by which a bishop can be made accountable either to the diocesan council and related bodies or to the Synod. Thus we have 22 fiefdoms which are ruled autocratically by a monarchical episcopate against the intentions and wishes of the founding fathers.





This situation is further complicated and worsened by the involvement of a subservient clergy and other employees of the diocese in decision making bodies. They become easy prey to threats and inducements. Transfers and postings in congregations and other institutions have been an important means of manipulating them to slavish obedience to the dictates of the bishops. Erosion in the standard of the clergy in their theological formation, general education, astuteness and moral fibre has also come to shape the subservient role and the sycophancy surrounding episcopal authority.





Vast assets, both landed properties and institutions, inherited from the missionaries at prime locations come in handy to the bishops to bolster their arrogance and dictatorial ways. CSI Trust Association (CSITA) is credited with the task of holding in trust the valuable properties bequeathed to us by the missionaries. The assets that the congregations have procured either as landed properties or church buildings and other commercial ventures are also given over to the CSITA. But then, the CSITA act without any authorisation from the local congregations, collude with the bishops and alienate valuable assets of the congregations when its role is solely to manage the properties on behalf of every member of the church and its congregations.





By its own admission in the income tax returns, the CSITA acknowledges that it is only “a bare and passive trustee”. A bare and passive trustee is one in whom property is vested simply for the benefit of another person till such time the cestui que trust claim possession of the property or deal with it as per his direction. As such, the CSITA cannot be a party to alienating lands and other assets of the church. While this is the real fact, the bishops and the Synod have been deluding the congregations and its members by its authoritarian ways and acting as if the CSITA can do whatever it pleases with the assets of the church and therefore have the right to alienate them at its will. However, the CSI constitution is very explicit in the understanding that it is only with the full consent of the congregation that the executive committee or the property committee can initiate any action to sell or lease any property of the trust. When it comes to properties that we have inherited from our forefathers or the missionaries, we are morally bound to use it for evangelistic purposes for which they have bequeathed them to us. However, today, instead of seeking new and relevant ways of evangelism and service to the community, the properties are perceived only in terms of its real estate value as in the case of Ahab, while the Christian attitude should be that of Naboth who had refused to alienate his vineyard for attractive terms of exchange, since the land was invaluable to him as “the inheritance of my fathers” (I Kings. Ch. 21: 14).





The injustice becomes more evident when one observes that a local community buys a piece of land and builds up a church and associated infrastructure; then, comes an “upstart” bishop touting his authority and scepter of excommunication to cow them to submission and to establish his will on them, be it a matter of posting a pastor, dismissing an elected committee without adequate reason or consultation, or even making an ecclesiastical visit without invitation or information and against the will of the congregation. These are things that really happen against the wishes of all those who have worked for the church union.





To a large extent, the shape episcopacy has taken in CSI is unimaginably more authoritarian with accumulated vested interests than that of the Eastern churches. These churches have a long history of hierarchical episcopate, but surely, hierarchical ordering in itself need not be authoritarian. As the bishops in the Eastern churches lead the life of an ascetic, a sanyasi, particularly, opting for a life of celibacy, in theory, these bishops are expected to confine their role to more theological and spiritual matters rather than to temporal concerns of property development and transactions. Moreover, an election to the bishopric is subject to multiple layers of screening process. The church would have a list of celibates from whom they could elect a presbyter to bishopric. From this list, shortlisting is undertaken by a screening committee, carefully scrutinising all aspects of the life of a clergy before he is presented before the Sabha Mandalam for voting for bishopric. This rigorous process of screening and shortlisting helps to ensure the integrity of those who are, then, voted to the office. Of course, this is not to say that, in practice, even the above mentioned process has not been subject to manipulation.










Bishop V. S. Azariah

In CSI, there is no such screening process. Even presbyters who do not have a basic B. D or M. Div theological degree and have character anomalies can contest and get elected to the panel for bishopric and then subsequently be nominated to this office by political manoeuvring and payoffs involving huge sums of money. There are bishops in CSI who have only a B. Th degree, but then, go around prefixing ‘Dr.’ to their names. While, in the earlier days, the CSI was known for its educated clergy both in secular and theological education, today the situation is just the reverse. The Eastern Orthodox/Jacobite Churches and the Marthoma Church generally have a well educated clergy, often trained in their own best theological seminaries. As a result, our standing in the ecumenical world has been considerably diminished. We do not have the kind of clergy or episcopal leadership as that of the stature of Bishop V. S. Azariah who could set the ecumenical agenda of his day and command the respect of an ecumenical community.





For the Eastern churches, more prominently the Marthoma Church, dioceses are not significant entities except for administrative management. Each diocese will have a bishop and associated councils and administrative structures; but they cannot be fiefdoms of a bishop. In theory, they remain accountable to the central authority constituted in the person of the Metropolitan, the Synod (the bishops’ council) and the Prathinidhi Mandalam, which is the apex body of the church, consisting of “the Metropolitan, all other Bishops, Vicars General, representatives of clergy and parishes, representatives of the recognised institutions of the Church, representatives of those who have become members of the Church as a result of the missionary work of the Church and persons nominated by the Metropolitan.” (Constitution of the Marthoma Church)





Particularly important is the fact that 65% of the membership in the Sabha Mandalam is from the laity and only 35% from the clergy. There are several layers of checks and balances. The laity, being in the majority, are expected to play a significant role in matters of administration and policy decisions (though in practice, this may not always be the case). The clergy-laity proportion even in the Malankara Syrian Christian Association is 1:2. But, till recently, the clergy-laity proportion in the diocesan councils and other administrative bodies of the North Kerala Diocese and of many other dioceses of the CSI have been highly skewed in favour of the clergy. When there is a predominance of the employees of the diocese in decision making bodies, either as clergy or employees in institutions, the chances for those in authority influencing them with threats and inducements will be very high. In the Marthoma Church, the transfer of clergy does not rest with the diocesan bishops, rather with the Metropolitan in the Synod.





Many things that have been happening in the CSI are against the protestant and reformed tradition and the enlightenment and democratic ethos that were associated with these historical movements. Democracy rests on two pillars: (1) the utter depravity and sinfulness of human beings and (2) the dignity of each human being as created in the image of God. The first, the deprived and sinful human condition affirms the fallibility of human beings and all human authorities, which, as a result, requires checks and balances within any system of governance. “Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely” (Lord Acton). Power of any human authority has to be checked and kept under control and democracy is believed to hold a promise in this direction.





Second, the Christian and biblical affirmation of human dignity is exemplified in the fact that human beings are created in God’s own image with certain inalienable rights and that no human being can be considered ‘worthless for whom Jesus Christ died’. Hence, democracy again is believed to hold the promise that every member of the society is respected and his/her views are heard. It is this democratic tradition that is being negated when a bishop repudiates the CSI constitution and takes on to himself “ecclesiastical authority”, which neither our tradition nor the constitution expect them to exercise. The Moderator and the Synod intervene only under extreme circumstances and by that time, enough damage may have already been done. Most often, the Synod and the Moderator cannot intervene as their credibility and moral stature would be worse than that of the diocesan bishops and their cronies. They also suffer from the same malignancy.





Once Synod elections are over, the Moderator and the General Secretary have a free hand in managing the affairs of the Synod without much checks and balances. Often Synod elections are fiercely contested with huge sums of money changing hands. Then, the newly elected executive committee and the Synod officers collude to ensure that their efforts are amply rewarded. Moreover, they remain far away from the people and the public glare except as people who are revered for the high office that they hold and the ‘divinity’ associated with it. They, then, elect themselves as the CSI Trust Association, and preside over the plundering of valuable assets passed on to them to the negation of their role as trustees. Recently, it has been the agenda of the bishops to initiate a number of “development” projects, a misnomer for engaging in activities by which they can regain the capital that they have transferred for nomination to bishopric. This involves starting self-financing professional courses such as B. Ed, Dental and Nursing Colleges, leasing out buildings and properties in prime locations, developing shopping complexes, and outright selling of lands, again in prime locations. This has come to the point where a bishop openly proclaims that the CSI is on a mission to explore the potential for a business venture in tourism. Appointments of teachers and admission of students are also occasions for illegal gratification.





The casualty is mission and evangelism, which is glossed over for developmental activities. Majority of Dalit parishes in rural areas have been lost to us through pastoral neglect. The schools and colleges of missionary days remain unattended and uncared for. The concern for equity and empowerment of the poor and the down trodden have been completely sidelined to accrue crass financial gain through self-financing institutions. Dalit has become a word used more often to attract foreign funds rather than a focus for solidarity, for social justice and liberative action. When the mission in education, the only cultural instrument that can provide equity and empower people, is turned into commercial ventures to benefit the elite of a given society, all the tall talk of mission in education become a sham and the memories of the missionary stalwarts who paid by their lives to establish such centres of knowledge especially for the most vulnerable sections of the society stands desecrated. Unity, renewal, mission slogans with which many of us grew up have ceased to be part of the vocabulary of the church; the people in the pew are left to fend for themselves and poached by all and sundry evangelists who come with bags of dollars. Even bishops fall prey to them. The CSI is also faced with the daunting task of convincing the people in the pew that they are the church and they are the “royal priesthood”, and more than being serviced by the clergy, they have a role in the world of “proclaiming the good news of the gospel and driving out the demons”. They are kept under submission by a mystique of divine power. The sacraments and the “full privileged membership” are considered means of salvation without which they are destined for perdition, rather than means of empowering oneself for the task of Christian witness in the world. The clergy intentionally furthers a theology and biblical interpretation that legitimises this perception of discipleship and the church being in the world as a religious community for its own salvation. This is further buttressed by the casteist and feudal world view and the related spiritual notions and practices that are very much part of the cultural milieu. And for a majority, church also means “favours”, once doled out by the missionaries and today by their counterparts in the persons of bishops and clergy.





There is nothing much to salvage except to ask the judiciary to put in place an officiating administration for an interim period and during which a commission constituted with the involvement of the partner churches may go into the various aspects of the structure and functioning of the CSI. And then, based on the commission’s recommendations, the CSI prepare itself for radical restructuring.





One direction in which this change can be envisaged is by stressing a more Congregationalist polity with its associated recognition of the theological emphasis on the priesthood of all believers and of the various gifts, ministries and operations which are given to us by the Holy Spirit for “building up the church”. Congregationalists played a prominent role in the formation of the CSI in 1947, and they also became part of the United Church of Canada and of the Uniting Church in Australia. The strong convictions concerning the sovereignty of God and the priesthood of all believers have led many of them to adopt a theological and social liberalism, and to participate in the ecumenical movement. The promise of a revival among the laity, their active and decisive involvement and participation in the life of the church and also their public witness in the secular world are inherent in a Congregationalist polity. The ordained ministry, in a Congregationalist polity will not easily be corrupted by any vestiges of “priesthood” and “priest craft” and will give way to an understanding of their role as that of an “elder”.





The history of congregationalism would reveal a strong emphasis on evangelism and a new political and social radicalism, a reaching out to the poorer sections of the society, an emphasis on democratic form of administration, and freedom from “dead works” and dead structures of religion to serve the living God. It acknowledges the rights and responsibilities of each properly organised congregation to determine its own affairs, without having to submit their decisions to the judgment of any higher human authority. Congregationalist polity is often criticised for its laxity in not sticking to right faith and practices arrived at through a more collective and corporate decision making process as it has been done in a diocesan/Synod polity. However, a diocesan/Synod polity is no guarantee that right faith and practice would be arrived at through collective consensus and that they would always be strictly adhered to. In the last 63 years of the CSI, no crucial matters of faith and practice have ever come up for serious debate or resolution in the dioceses or Synod except that of women’s ordination. The CSI is least concerned about right faith and practice. One of the former moderators of the church had his hands laid on a lay preacher from another sectarian church without the sanction of the Synod executive committee and consecrate him as a bishop without any consequence to his office. Another CSI bishop, who had been part of the same action, was later elected/promoted to be the moderator of the CSI. Moreover, it is also a fact that a Congregationalist polity never stands in the way of a confederation or convention of the congregations to deliberate on such matters and lend itself to seeking God’s will in community with the leading of the Holy Spirit as in the case of the Jerusalem council (Acts 15: 119)





The congregational emphasis could be kept in balance with a Presbyterian polity in the office of episcopate. During the negotiation for church union, the South India Union of Churches (SIUC) faction, which comprised of the Congregationalists and the Presbyterians, was very much concerned about the shape that episcopacy would assume in an authoritarian, hierarchically ordered and caste-ridden society like India. Their worst fears have come true and the Episcopal and Anglican traditions have completely taken over the manner and content of the church’s presence and witness in the world and have become a source of much corruption in high places.





The suggested changes are not easy to come by. The entrenched forces of evil, injustice and oppression will not easily give up their “ecclesiastical privileges”. And a change can be effected only with much zeal and suffering equaling the one that was shown during the union negotiations. With majority of the members being indifferent to what is happening in the church except the respectability associated with it, a popular uprising cannot be expected at the moment. But a spiritual revival under a charismatic leadership or a sustained effort by a remnant prepared for the long haul, bearing the cross, could be a promising prospect that can change history around. In any case, all this calls for a complete overhaul and a radical restructuring without which CSI will have no future. It is already dead spiritually and is stinking. Repentance and Prayer in “sack clothes and ashes” by a fearless and committed group of laity, a remnant, is the need of the hour. Hope and pray that the spirit of Christ would sweep over us all and make us live.





Then I heard the voice of the Lord saying, ‘Whom shall I send, and who will go for us?’ And I said, ‘Here am I; send me!’ And he said, ‘Go and say to this people: “Keep listening, but do not comprehend;keep looking, but do not understand.” Make the mind of this people dull, and stop their ears, and shut their eyes, so that they may not look with their eyes, and listen with their ears, and comprehend with their minds, and turn and be healed.’ Then I said, ‘How long, O Lord?’ And he said: ‘Until cities lie waste without inhabitant, and houses without people, and the land is utterly desolate; until the Lord sends everyone far away, and vast is the emptiness in the midst of the land. Even if a tenth part remains in it, it will be burned again,like a terebinth or an oak whose stump remains standing when it is felled.’ The holy seed is its stump. (Isaiah 6: 8-13)


10 January 2019

"Son of man, can these bones live?" (Ezekiel 37:3)



Rev. Thomas John





It was at the behest and insistence of the people of Israel that Yahweh, the God of Israel, allowed Samuel to anoint Saul as the King of Israel. Yahweh, through the prophet Samuel, communicated to the people the oppression and exploitation that would entail the appointment of a King over Israel. (1 Samuel 8: 10-22) But yet, "the people refused to listen to Samuel. 'No!' they said. 'We want a king over us. Then we will be like all the other nations, with a king to lead us and to go out before us and fight our battles.'" (1 Samuel 8: 19, 20) Subsequently, the same people who insisted on having a king went through some of the worst experiences of monarchical rule under both, Saul and Solomon.






During the negotiations for church union, the non-episcopal churches cautioned that episcopacy as a form of church polity is fraught with dangerous consequences especially in a society steeped in a feudal culture. Yet, despite their warnings, the negotiators, imbued with an urgency for union, went ahead and accepted episcopacy as a form of church government that was in existence since the inception of the church (historic) without subscribing to any theological position associated with it which has a history in the western world. Today, the prophetic warnings of the non-episcopal churches have become a reality and the chicken has come home to roost. In the CSI, episcopacy has become monarchical; it has become ruthless, tyrannical, and exploitative without any regard for the calling and mission of the church.





The Bishops in CSI, without any exception, either by their active participation or silent complicity have allowed themselves to be, both literally and figuratively, like the shepherds of Israel as described in the book Ezekiel, Ch. 34, "Woe to you shepherds of Israel who only take care of yourselves! Should not shepherds take care of the flock? You eat the curds, clothe yourselves with the wool and slaughter the choice animals, but you do not take care of the flock. You have not strengthened the weak or healed the sick or bound up the injured. You have not brought back the strays or searched for the lost. You have ruled them harshly and brutally."





On 11 December 2018, the Crime Investigation Department (CID) arrested the former moderator of the Church of South India, Rt. Rev. G. Dyvasirvadam for his alleged involvement in the misappropriation of church funds and properties. He was produced before the local court, which remanded him to a 14 day judicial custody. The former moderator is languishing in jail even as I write this article. His arrest has happened in the light of various financial scams that the CSITA has been involved in. In 2015, the Registrar of Companies had found that the CSITA was not providing a clear picture of its accounts and had not maintained a list of its properties. Subsequently, it was also found that the CSITA had made amendments to its rule book without the Centre's approval. Considering the financial irregularities unearthed so far, the CID estimates that the scam runs into several thousand crores of rupees. The arrest and role of the former moderator in this scam is only a tip of the iceberg. The CID is continuing the investigation and there are more skeletons yet to tumble out of the closet, involving not just moderators, but several other bishops too.  (For detailed news reports, see: CID Arrests CSI Archbishop Dyvarsirvadam for Church Fund Scam; Misuse of Church Funds: CID Inspects CSI Office)





The Church of South India has had several saintly souls who served as bishops and moderators. The Rt. Rev. Isaiah Jesudason, was the last of such moderators. He was the moderator from 1982-87, and was someone who had to be persuaded to become a moderator. They were illustrious, yet humble and always adopted a simple and penurious lifestyle, keeping in mind the distinctiveness of the episcopacy in CSI. Since 1987, electoral politics and money changing hands became necessary for one to become a bishop. Associated with that came the formation of mafias that made and unmade bishops and decided on the politics of the CSI Synod. These mafias subsequently thrived on selling and leasing of CSI properties and "developing" church properties involving crores of rupees for shopping complexes etc. Mission ceased to be an agenda for the church. Bishopric became a good investment one could make expecting good returns.





Matters came to worse with the globalization and liberalization agenda of the state in the 1990s. Private agencies were allowed to establish self-financing educational institutions, especially professional colleges to be run almost as commercial ventures with capitation fee for admissions. This also marked the death of mission schools and colleges. They no longer were in the mission priorities. Though they (aided schools and colleges) continued to be milking cows that fetched enormous money for the appointment of teachers, they continued to face neglect. Minority rights, provided by the Indian constitution for minorities to establish and run educational institutions came in handy for this power seeking, wealth seeking, mafia to make enormous black money and acquire associated social and political clout, through starting self-financing professional educational institutions. It is these goons that decide the diocesan and synod politics. The ordinary people in the pew were made happy with a veneer of revivals and miracle crusades which further ensured unreserved obedience to ecclesiastics. "Mafiasation" of the church was thus made complete, and Jesus Christ and his mission was left to fend for itself.





One apt example of this is the Dr. Somervell Memorial CSI Medical College, Karakonam. This medical college determines to a large extent the politics of the diocese. This college has become the hot-bed of corruption; and often the existing ruling political formation plays second fiddle to it. The diocese, with its Nadar (caste) base and strength as a vote bank, is decisive in determining the politics of the state too. The medical college was able to influence the government to issue G.O (Rt) No. 2031/2018/H&FWD dated 25.06.2018, that revised the seat matrix for two colleges, Dr. Somervell Memorial CSI Medical College and the Believers Church Medical College, Thiruvalla for the academic year 2018-19. As per this government order, an additional 5th category was added to augment the minority community and NRI quota seats by including "Members/Associate Members of CSI other than South Kerala Diocese and Members/Associate Members from CMS Anglican Church" and thus privileging the management to broaden the scope of admitting all and sundry under minority community quota and indulging in gross sale of seats for medical education.





On the plea of a few students belonging to the South Kerala Diocese (SKD)/South India Union of Churches (SIUC) that their rights to community quota seats have been denied by fraudulently bringing in students from other communities, the High Court of Kerala ordered that the Admission Fee Regulator Committee (AFRC) headed by Hon. Justice R. Rajendra Babu must review the admission of students for the year 2018-2019. The committee as part of its inquiry, had cross examined the Bishop of the SKD, Rt. Rev. A Dharmaraj Rasalam and the Moderator of CSI, the Most Rev. Thomas K Oommen. The following are excerpts from the AFRC report/order. They are highly revealing of the collusion of these ecclesiastics in this fraudulent action.







"The Bishop (Bp. Rasalam) stated before the committee that the reason for change in the seat matrix from the Government order dated 23.06.2018 to Ext. P11 dated 25.06.2018, including CMS Anglican Churches/Diocese was as per the recommendation of Admission Committee of the CSI Church, of which he was the chairman... Though such a statement was made, no reliable evidence could be produced to establish the same and the above version cannot be believed in its face value... In the above circumstances, the assignment of 15 seats to the CMS Anglican Churches could be with ulterior motives of collecting bribes as alleged in the complaints filed before the committee."





The committee pointed out: "The reservation of seats under minority community quota is available only to the community which established the college, viz CSI (SIUC). The evidence in this matter would show that CMS Anglican Churches are totally independent separate religious denomination which has no connection with CSI or SIUC. It would be relevant to note that CMS Anglican Churches were not included in the community quota in the prospectus. The assignment or inclusion of CMS Anglican Churches in the minority community quota at a very late stage appears to be with ulterior motives."





The nine students who sought admission with certificate from a certain Rt. Rev. David V. Lukose under this category do "not belong to the community CMS Anglican Church and they belonged to other denominations of Christian community and the certificate issued by Rt. Rev. David V Lukose are fake. Further, the committee finds that the admission of the above students in the minority community quota "Members/Associate Members of CMS Anglican Church" cannot be approved and are liable to be rejected."





Any person with some common sense and integrity would not believe that Bishop Rasalam and the Most Rev. Thomas K Oommen were unaware of the fact that this bogus bishop (David V Lukose) is a creation of the mafia working around the medical college to hood wink the authorities. The Rt. Rev. David V Lukose is a fraud created for the purpose of swindling money by those who are in positions of power, including the Bishops. How cleverly have they tried to cheat the system and make money!





According to the committee, one of the candidates, Mr. Aaron Abraham Philip got admission in the category Members/Associate Members of CMS Anglican Church. When examined, he stated that he belonged to the CSI Church and that CSI and the CMS Anglican Churches are one and the same. The Most. Rev. Thomas K Oommen had also issued the minority community certificate to Sri. Aaron Abraham Philip stating that he belonged to "Members/ Associate Members of CMS Anglican Church." The Moderator, when examined "stated that CSI (SIUC) and CMS Anglican Churches are totally different religious denominations and he issued the certificate without verifying any documents."





The committee points its finger to the premeditated lie of the Bishop when it states: "Even the above certificate issued by the Bishop would reveal that Aaron Abraham Philip is a member of CSI Christ Church, Thiruvananthapuram. The certificate issued by the Vicar Rev. C. Y. Thomas also would show that Aaron Abraham Philip is a member of CSI Christ Church. In fact, the Bishop of CSI, Madhya Kerala Diocese is not competent to issue a certificate as "Member/ Associate Member of CMS Anglican Church... The evidence would establish that Aaron Abraham Philip is a member of CSI Church and not Member/ Associate Member of CMS Anglican Church and hence, his admission to the MBBS course in the above community quota cannot be approved and is liable to be rejected." Should we then just assume from all this that our moderator is ignorant and foolish? (For detailed news reports, see: 11 MBBS Admissions at Kerala Medical College Declared Void by AFRC; Admissions to 11 Seats Declared Void; സർട്à´Ÿിà´«ിà´•്à´•à´±്à´±് à´µിà´µാà´¦ം: à´¬ിà´·à´ª്à´ª് à´¡േà´µിà´¡് à´µി à´²ൂà´•്à´•ോà´¸് à´µ്à´¯ാജനെà´¨്à´¨് ആരോപണം)





The church has been facing an extremely difficult situation ever since the National Company Law Tribunal removed all the directors and office bearers managing the CSI and installed Retired Justice K. Sampath as its chairman in 2016. In October 2016, the Ministry of Corporate Affairs had engaged the Serious Fraud Investigation Office to probe the alleged balance-sheet irregularities of the CSITA. Subsequently, the National Company Law Tribunal stated that "there is an urgent need to regulate the affairs of the R1 company (Church of South India Trust Association)" and hence, it removes "all the directors and managing committee including office bearers..." Further, "the erstwhile management committee is directed to hand over all the documents and books of accounts and other records of the R1 company to the Registry of this bench is a sealed cover within a week from the date of pronouncement of this order..." (For detailed news report: Company Law Tribunal Dismantles Top Order at Church of South India: Appoints Retired Judge; Church of South India Caught in a Web of Irregularities)





Instead of squarely facing the facts and trying to set the house in order, this news was conveniently kept hidden from the people and everything seemed to go on as usual. The ousted Honorary Secretary of the trust, Daniel R. Sadananda and the Honorary Treasurer, Robert Bruce moved the High Court seeking to quash the order.





But the law has been catching up and the High Court (Madras) dismissed the appeal on 23 December 2018. The Times of India reported: "In a major setback to the erstwhile management of the Church of South India T.A, the Madras high Court has dismissed the appeal challenging the order passed by the NCLT, removing all directors, management committee including office bearers of the Trust and appointing a former Judge of the Court as the Chairman to manage its affairs." 





The boat that is the church is still drifting. The thugs in it may still be planning for other legal options. They can still appeal to the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT). It is doubtful whether they would take recourse to such measures before an extremely competent professional investigating body. The CSITA does not even have a register of its immovable assets including landed property.





This is a time for all of us to repent in dust and ashes. The silent majority fails to take up their discipleship seriously; they fail to recognize the church as the called out people, sent out by Jesus Christ, to carry forward Christ's mission in the world. We also have turned the church into a member's only club that would add to our respectability. We pay obeisance to these bishops and pastors to add value to our baptisms, weddings, and funerals. We work with a false missiology and ecclesiology (theology of mission and church). We have failed in realizing that the whole paraphernalia of ecclesiastics is to equip the saints, us the laity, for their mission in the world. We have somehow mistaken the church for the ecclesiastical and have been pumping enormous resources to maintain it. We have elevated pastors, shepherds to 'priests', and failed to realize that we as the church have been called to be God's holy and royal priesthood. We have allowed ourselves to be slaves to these shepherds in wolf's clothing. It is high time that we retrieve our rightful place in the church.



The ecclesiastical heads, who have brought the church to this impasse can still continue to allow the boat that is the church to drift. We cannot expect from any of these people an iota of repentance, unless God intervenes. As I write this, instead listening to the voice of sanity, they are ruthlessly stifling all voices of dissent, without any constitutional morality or civility. They have lost their cool. They have become like Saul who was possessed by the evil spirit. "Now the Spirit of the Lord departed from Saul, and a harmful spirit from the Lord tormented him" (1 Samuel 16:14) He was possessed by a sense of revenge. But, still let us pray that finally God's Spirit to prevail.





I suggest that we consider taking the following infant steps to deal with this Goliath in front of us:





1. We must network among us and create a Fellowship that covers the entire CSI jurisdiction. We need to work first for a spiritual revival/renewal; something of what John the Baptist demanded. I am not asking for retrogressive emotional piety, but rather reminding us of our calling to be Jesus' disciples transcending our church-going and church-centered Christianity that we often wear over our shoulders. We need to rediscover our mission and our vocation as a Church. We should remind ourselves and our friends that we are the Church, not the bishops and the Presbyters. The Church - the one, Holy, Catholic, Apostolic Church - is present in all its fullness in the local worshipping community. Congregation must become the focus; people must become the focus and not the ecclesiastics or ecclesiastical paraphernalia.





2. We should bring to the awareness of people the real situation we are in as a church. We should not allow an information overload to clog information from reaching our constituencies. We should find a way to use our social media in a more streamlined manner and not merely for our self-expression.





3. We should get our theologians, retired and serving pastors and a wider group of informed lay leadership together to talk about an alternative church polity and church governance that would remedy the kind of dangers we are in and facilitate our Christian witness in this land. If the church administration goes into the hands of a secular administration, it is important that we reach a consensus at the earliest regarding the way we should organize ourselves as an institution and present the same to the appropriate bodies so that we could start on a clean slate with clear sense of direction.





Let me conclude by drawing your attention to an article, The City in Ruins: the Story of an Ecumenical Vision Betrayed, that I had written in 2011. It is a reflection on the present reality of the church and posing an alternative model of church governance that we can think of. I invite your comments on it. You can also access me in my email address: revthomasjohn@gmail.com.





May God use us despite our frailties to turn the church around to fulfil its mission! Let us continue to pray and work for its revival and renewal.





28 December 2018

Can financial fraud be ignored in the name of forgiveness and reconciliation?








An Open Letter to Rt Rev P. K. Samuel, Bishop, Karnataka Central Diocese of the CSI, on his Christmas Eve Homily at St. Mark's Cathedral, Bengaluru, 24th December 2018.






Dear  Bishop,







Greetings to you in the name of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ.









I was in the congregation at St. Mark’s Cathedral  during the Christmas eve late night service this week and listened with great interest to your homily. The theme of peace and reconciliation you chose was very much in keeping with both the Christmas spirit and the need of the challenging times we live in. You also made a passing reference to the “serious difficulties” being encountered by the church and mentioned unnamed people creating “divisions” within the church.










This piece is an attempt to provide some reasoned feedback on your sermon  with the hope that  it will lead to reflection and positive action by you and your peers to rescue the CSI from the dire situation it finds itself in.









As you are aware, two recent developments have greatly impacted the reputation of the CSI negatively. First  the arrest and jailing of the former moderator two weeks ago (he remains in jail at the time of writing with his  bail plea having been rejected) on serious charges of corruption and alleged looting of over Rs 500 crore worth of church property. The second is the dismissal last week by the Madras High Court of the revision petition that sought to set aside the order of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) that divested the office bearers of the CSITA of their powers to manage the vast wealth  of the CSI and appointed a retired judge (since deceased) in its place. No doubt the “serious difficulties" you mentioned in passing, without elaborating, had to do with both these developments, particularly the latter.









In your sermon you repeatedly made the case for striving  for peace and reconciliation, both as individuals and as a society. But, with due respect, you failed to mention two important conditions that are sine qua non for bringing about peace and reconciliation, whether within  the church or in the wider world outslde it. And that is the requirement for justice and forgiveness.  This is so important that it needs to be stated in capital letters. THERE CAN BE NO PEACE AND RECONCILIATION WITHOUT JUSTICE AND FORGIVENESS.









In your sermon you made a reference to Bishop Desmond Tutu of South Africa and how as a child he was greatly moved by the gesture of a white man in racist South Africa stepping aside for him and his mother to pass on the  road when the prevailing rule was that it was the blacks who were to step aside for the white man.  Well, you must know that Bishop Tutu is a good example of someone who helped successfully advance the cause of peace and reconciliation in an entire country by ensuring restorative (as distinct from retributive) justice. The Truth and Reconciliation Commission heheaded at the request of Nelson Mandela helped heal the wounds of apartheid through  open hearings which saw Bishop Tutu himself overcome with emotion and crying openly; The net effect of this cathartic process was that the ends of justice were served (as many as 5392 amnesty applications were rejected by the Commission which had the power to grant amnesty) even as thousands of victims were able to accept the forgiveness openly sought in public by their tormentors and achieve peace both for themselves as well as the society at large.









What the CSI needs to achieve is peace and reconciliation, and save itself from the dire predicament it finds itself in. My humble views are the following:









1) An acknowledgement by the powers that be in the CSI that serious crimes have been committed against God and His church by those in power. If you have any doubt as to the widespread nature of just the financial crimes then this link will provide some striking and shocking examples. And this piece does not even refer to the depredations of the former Moderator who is currently behind bars.









2) An acknowledgement that  not every CSI member who has  gone legal against the Church is its enemy. It is precisely because the church ignored appeals to rein in the rampant corruption that many were forced to go to the courts seeking justice for the church. More importantly the time has come to recognise that the dissenters are achieving  significant legal success as illustrated by the  NCLT order. It is not longer wise to dismiss them  as inconsequential beings working against the interest of the church. Rather, the very survival of the church would require that the CSI at the highest level enter into a dialogue with the dissenters, something successive moderators have failed to do. Such a reaching out is important to  prevent the very real possibility that continued legal battles could eventually force the courts to put the church’s vast wealth in government hands as has already been partially  done by the NCLT order.









3) An acknowledgement that those mandated to protect the church have failed to discharge their fiduciary duties to the church’s 4 million strong membership. Despite hundreds of crores worth of church property having been looted over decades (as illustrated in the link cited above), the complaints to the authorities have always emanated from individual CSI members. The closest any CSITA authority came to act in this regard was when former CSI general secretary and CSITA secretary Rev Moses Jayakumar filed a police complaint against this predecessor for swindling Tsunami funds.







No senior functionary of the CSITA (which technically holds all property of the CSI) has thought it fit all these years to complain to the authorities against a bishop, whether serving or retired,  for recovery of the looted property. Even in the latest case involving the jailed former Moderator, it is distressing that the  no official complaint has been filed by the Church leadership seeking recovery of the stolen properties. This is a stark example of denying God’s church the very basic element  of justice due to it.









In my view, if the bishops of the CSI want genuine peace and reconciliation within the church they need to, at a minimum, acknowledge the three “wrongs” listed above. I am confident that if this is done, the right atmosphere will be created to wind down the court cases and for the CSI to have its own Truth and Reconciliation Commission. The focus, as in South Africa, should be on restorative (not retributive) justice where restitution (even partially) of what has been illegally taken away goes hand in hand with forgiveness of those who have wronged the church and now show repentance.









I have no illusions this will be an easy task. But if we fervently pray for it, God will provide the right person. The CSI would need its own Bishop Desmond Tutu to pilot the entire process starting with the most difficult bit – the acknowledgement of the three wrongs. But till the right person emerges all talk of peace and reconciliation within the church will, I am afraid, remain just that: talk.









Here's wishing you all the very best for the New Year and for your ministry.









Yours in Christ







Binu Samuel Thomas




26th December 2018



17 December 2018

An open letter to the Most Rev Thomas K Oommen, Moderater of CSI




An Open Letter


to Most Rev Thomas K. Oommen, Moderator, Church of South India


on the arrest and jailing of the former CSI Moderator






Dear Moderator,









I write as a CSI member to  convey my deep anguish at the silence of the church over a very shameful  episode that has been playing out in full public view for a while and reached its crescendo this week.  As you are no doubt aware, your immediate predecessor as Moderator Bishop Govada Dyvasirvadam was arrested and jailed  a few days ago on serious charges of misappropriating hundreds of crores worth of church property. Some of the news reports  relating to this are below:


















You may recall that the former moderator was arrested even in January this year and his  (and the CSI’s other) shenanigans were laid bare in this detailed article below by one of the CSI’s own ordained ministers 




















Moderator, the issue that pains me is that while an office bearer of the Krishna Godavari diocese has initiated the complaint against the former moderator, the Synod and the CSITA (both of which you head) are silent about the hundreds of crores of property that has been swindled. Is it asking too much that the CSITA (which holds all property of the CSI and is currently under your leadership) take strong legal action (both civil and criminal) against the former moderator? Is it also asking too much that you suspend his pension and other benefits at least during the pendency of the legal proceedings against him?









The Editor’s Guild of India recently suspended the membership of former minister and journalist M.J. Akbar who is alleged to have misbehaved with several women colleagues more than two decades ago. Why is it that the CSI is unwilling to even suspend the pension of its former moderator and more importantly take legal action against him to recover valuable church property that has been swindled? 









 It is highly regrettable that successive moderators (as heads of the CSITA) have refused to maintain a central property register detailing all the properties of the CSI in the five southern states that are worth several lakhs of crores. Such a centralized register of properties should not only be prepared without delay but should be made public so that each CSI member is aware of the vast tracts of church property that exist in his neighborhood. This is the best insurance there is to prevent their alienation for the private gain of those in power. The excuse that preparing such a record will make unfriendly governments covet church property is not valid as governments have ways and means to get such information if they so desire.









I hope in the remaining period you have as a moderator you will take steps to create and make public a centralized property register of the CSI as also as join the legal proceedings against the former moderator to ensure valuable church property is recovered and used for the greater glory of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ.  I also hope you will inform the 4 million strong church membership of your actions in this regard.









Thanking you




Yours in Christ









Binu Samuel Thomas





































Bengaluru








03 November 2015

The Future of Episcopacy in the Church of South India



Statement of the Consultation organized by the
People Synod at Vellore, Tamil Nadu, on 17th October, 2015 on the topic “ The
Future of Episcopacy in the Church of South India” A Consultation was organized by the newly launched
People Synod, in cooperation with the Abundant Life Movement, Vellore on 17th
October, 2015 at Vellore, Tamil Nadu. The Consultation was attended by about 100 CSI
members, both clergy and laity, from all the regions of the Church of South
India. 


Background
of the Consultation



It is well recognized now that the CSI is in a
state of deep crisis. Issues relating to transparency and accountability in
administration, autocratic and unresponsive leadership and wide spread
allegations of corruption reported in the media, have begun to exercise the
minds of a large number of members. In the matter of management of movable and immovable
properties of the CSI, supposed to be the responsibility of the Church of South
India Trust Association (CSI TA), a Company registered under the Companies Act,
serious shortcomings have come to the attention of the Ministry of Corporate
Affairs and the Department of Income Tax of the Government of India. The CSI TA
is literally Reeling under investigations and show cause notices for serious
violations of the laws of the land . The threat of an investigation by the
Serious Fraud Investigation Office of the Central Government is looming large.
First Information Reports ( the first step for criminal investigation) have
been filed against several bishops in Police Stations of South India.





The most unfortunate thing is that the Episcopal
leadership not only refuses to acknowledge the crisis and to take remedial
action, but is embarking on a systematic attempt to distort the basic
principles on which the CSI Constitution was framed. While the Governing
Principles found in the CSI Constitution clearly affirmed that the Episcopal,
Presbyteral and Congregational elements are necessary in the life of the Church
in a well balanced manner, an undisguised attempt is made to make the Episcopal
element , represented by the Bishops, more dominant, sidelining the presbyteral
and congregational elements. To give constitutional legitimacy to this
distortion, a set of amendments and byelaws is sought to be thrust on the
people, vigorously pushed through by the Bishops led by the Moderator himself
to get the ratification of the Diocesan Councils. Alarmed by this development
and considering the protests that have emanated from various quarters, the
Consultation was called to consider the future of episcopacy in the CSI.


Discussion




The participants listened to various speakers who
analyzed the dangerous implications of the new amendments and byelaws, updated
the present state of affairs on the attempts to expose the maladministration
and corruption in the affairs of the CSI TA and the role of the People Synod in
organizing groups of people to coordinate the protests of the people against
the present dangerous trends in all aspects of the life of the Church. Members
shared their experience of the autocratic and undemocratic functioning of the Bishops
stifling the voices of the clergy and laity. The principles on which the CSI
was formed as stated in the Basis of the Union, later incorporated in the
Chapter on the 
Governing Principles of the Church were reviewed.
The role of the Bishops, Elders and Pastors in the administration of the early
Church and their equivalence and differences were considered. The fact that the
CSI Constitution is unregistered making it difficult for people to legally
challenge ongoing constitutional violations was highlighted.. After a detailed
discussion, the Consultation came to certain conclusions.



Conclusions





  1. There
    is indeed a deliberate attempt to make the CSI fully Episcopal with the vested
    interest of centralizing power and authority in Bishops for personal gains, eclipsing
    the presbyteral and congregational elements.

  2. The
    historic Episcopate in a Constitutional form accepted by the Uniting Churches
    for the sake of Unity is being distorted beyond recognition. Instead of the
    Bishops performing spiritual oversight while presiding over the diocesan council,
    bulk of the administrative responsibilities have been taken over by them.

  3. The
    usurpation of powers by the Bishops coupled with the practice of issuing Power
    of attorney to the Bishops is the underlying cause for widespread corruption.

  4. The
    new amendments and byelaws should be rejected out of hand as they go against
    the pledge that was given at the time of Union that a) the United Church does
    not mandate any particular interpretation of Episcopacy and no such particular
    interpretation shall be demanded from any minister or member ,b) the CSI needs
    the heritage of each of the Uniting Churches(Anglican, Methodist, Presbyterian
    and Congregational) and each of those Churches will not lose the continuity of
    its own life but preserve that life enriched by the union with other traditions
    and c) that there will not be absorption of anyone of the traditions by the
    other traditions.


In the light of the discussions and the conclusions
arrived at, the following Resolutions were passed.



Resolutions


Resolved





  1. That
    the People Synod should support and coordinate the resistance that is being shown
    in different parts of the CSI against the dangerous trend that is emerging in the
    CSI as stated above;

  2. That
    we whole heartedly support the attempts that are being made by Associations like
    the CSI TA Beneficiaries Association and individuals to expose the maladministration
    of the CSI TA and to seek the assistance of Statutory bodies to set right the
    affairs of the CSI TA in accordance with Companies Act 2013 and to bring to
    book the perpetrators of corrupt actions (Nehemiah needed the help of a non-Jewish
    King to rebuild the walls of Jerusalem)

  3. That
    the People Synod should take the initiative , on behalf of the People of God, to
    prepare a complete and comprehensive new Constitution in the form of a Scheme
    for administration and governance of the CSI reflecting both the intentions of
    the original founders of the CSI and the hopes and aspirations of the present
    members of the Church.

  4. That
    Partner Churches who are representatives of the Churches involved in the Union
    negotiations be apprised of these developments and the compelling circumstances
    which are forcing the people to take this step and seek their counsel.

  5. That
    in pursuance of Resolution 3, a process of consultation with all stakeholders be
    expeditiously started.

  6. That
    once such a Constitution/Scheme is ready, it may be placed before the people for
    their acceptance and support and the People Synod should explore ways and means
    of the possibility of getting legal status for it through registration under appropriate
    law of the land.










Dr. R. Jayakaran Isaac


11/1, Church Colony


Viruthampet, Vellore 632 006


Tamil Nadu, India Tamil Nadu, India


+ 91 94432 49422















Rev. Jacob Belly


31, Kandasamy Street


Kaundampalayam, Coimbatore 641 030


Tamil Nadu, India


+91 94432 13836

















For and on behalf of the People Synod.


27 October 2015

The Liar and Father of Lies



The Moderator of CSI Submits False Affidavit









It is sad to find the Ecclesiastics of CSI showing scant regard for the law of the land and the constitution of the Church. They seem to have become law unto themselves. In John 8:44, Jesus refers to his opponents as children of the devil and then goes on to describe the devil as a “liar and father of lies”. Of course this refers to their behaviour of obscuring the truth about Jesus Christ. But how would we understand the behaviour of the Moderator of the Church of South India and his fellow Bishops, if they grievously error on the side of falsehood questioning the very existence of a God who watches over us and our behavior?








It is with great dismay that these instances of grievous moral turpitude the Moderator of CSI are brought to the public. The Moderator had not only acted fraudulently to subvert the judicial system but also made a mockery of the democratic process in the dioceses.





The Addl. District & Sessions Judge, Miryalaguda, (Telangana State) issued an injunction in I. A. No. 340 of 2015 on 6th April 2015 restraining the Moderator and the Synod officers from making the proposed amendments to the present constitution of the CSI till 15-04-2015 when the matter would be heard in detail. The proposed amendments pertain to increasing the retirement age of the pastors and thereby that of the bishops from 65 to 67, extending the term of a Synod from 2 to 3 years and also taking away the democratic system of electing officers of the Synod and Dioceses.





However, without giving scant regard for the injunction/the judicial order and the law of this land, the Synod met on April 8 and 9 and passed the amendments to the constitution. The Synod General Secretary announced this decision of the synod to the Dioceses and others concerned on April 14 for further action by the Diocesan Councils.





Without any moral compunction, the moderator and the officers, in their sworn counter affidavit dated 15-04-2015 to the I.A. No. 340 of 2015 in the Additional District Court of Miriyalaguda, stated that “Synod Council that was convened on 8th and 9th April after a series of meetings of the constitution committee and the Synod Executive did not make any proposed amendments to the present constitution.” They submitted this blatant falsehood in their sworn affidavit to escape from the charge of contempt of Court. The Court disposed of the case accepting the sworn affidavit of the Moderator and with the rider that if any action follows contrary to this, the complainants can approach the court again.”





Since then, the moderator has been working overtime to call the meetings of the Diocesan Councils and ratify the amendments which, by his own sworn affidavit, had not been passed by the Synod. The CSI Constitution Ch. 13, 2/c, require ratification by two thirds of the Diocesan Councils for the amendments to come in force. Only amendments passed by the Synod can be put to vote in the Diocesan Councils. The moderator is guilty of committing contempt of court; he desecrated the very honorable position that he holds as Bishop and Moderator of the Church of South India by falsely representing facts before the honorable court; he made the Diocesan Council members of the 24 dioceses look fools by misleading them into voting for an amendment that by his own sworn affidavit, had not been passed. He had no legitimacy, moral or otherwise to continue in the leadership of the CSI.  





The Moderator has been resorting to arm-twisting, intimidations and all sorts of illegal means to get these amendments passed by the Diocesan Councils as early as possible. In the Malabar Diocesan Council, it was brought up for consideration and announced as passed, when it was not even an item in the agenda of the Council. The Moderator was physically present to bulldoze this amendment in the Malabar Diocesan Council. In the Diocesan Council of Kochi, the bishop introduced the amendment as passed by the Synod falsely representing facts or else making a fool of himself by believing the letter from the General Secretary. The bishop must explain and make his stand very clear. How do you deal with a moderator who utters blasphemous lies and makes a fool out of the believers?





These incidents point to an extremely alarming state of complete subversion of all democratic processes, especially in the context of an indifferent and apathetic laity. Why this much of haste to get a few amendments passed which do not pose any life and death issue except that the serving moderator’s intention to continue in the same office for another term would be thwarted. He needs compliant chum has to be in the positions of Treasurer and General Secretary so that his misdeeds and misappropriations can be covered. In Dioceses, the Bishops need compliant officers. Thus, their interests coincide to allow also sorts of illegalities.





The same interests are rallying around a bye-law which the Synod Executive proposed and subsequently, passed by the Synod in contravention of CSI constitution that all Officers are to be elected by ballot. The Bye-law addresses almost the same kind of concerns represented in the amendments to the constitution. Using these bye-laws which are against the very constitutional provisions of the CSI, elections were held in the Malabar Diocese; elections are announced to be held in the Cochi Diocese. Bishops and the moderator seem to be bent on taking the believers for a ride. The moderator must step down owning responsibility for this grave moral turpitude. If not, he will have to face criminal charges against fraudulent act of submitting false affidavit.  





We all make mistakes and as humans, Bishops also err. But, falsely representing facts by a sworn affidavit, calculated to cover the tracks is a very deliberate act of sin and it is an act of sin against the Holy Spirit and such a bishop cannot remain in office; he has lost all moral credibility to continue in this office. Or else the Synod Executive must meet and throw him out. Hope there will be remnant to stand up for the truth.





Mr. T. J. John